The Parish of All Saints began in the old St. Matthew's School Chapel on Humber Road. The chapel in the present church still holds some of the furniture from St. Matthews.
All Saints, along with the Rectory, was built in 1961 by members of the congregation. The Parish was a member of the Parish of Corner Brook until 1970 when it became an independent Parish known as the Parish of Corner Brook East. In 1980, the church was renamed the Parish of All Saints'. Currently, All Saints' congregation consists of over 400 families.
| Rev. Guy Fowlow|| 1961 - 1970|
|Rev. Gordon Pevie||1970 - 1973|
|Bishop Leonard Whitten|| 1973 - 1978|
|Rev. Tom Moulton|| 1978- 1984|
|Canon David Pearce|| 1984 - 1994|
| Rev. Martin Lane|| 1994 - 1996|
| Rev. Percy D. Coffin|| 1996 - 2003|
| Rev. Monica Coffin|| 2003 - 2004|
| Rev. Derek Thomas|| 2004 - 2010|
| Rev. Tanya R. White|| 2010- Present|